Thursday, May 13, 2010

Bee minus

The bee is small among flying creatures,
     but what it produces is the best of sweet things.

- Ecclesiasticus 11.3

The writer of Ecclesiasticus knew how wonderful honey is, but honey is only the second best gift we receive from bees.Yesterday's post may have been too obscure for some. I was attempting to draw attention to the latest UN report on global biodiversity Global Biodiversity Outlook 3, which is not a happy read. Here is a summary paragraph from page 67:
"The trends from available indicators suggest that the state of biodiversity is declining, the pressures upon it are increasing, and the benefits derived by humans from biodiversity are diminishing, but that the responses to address its loss are increasing. The overall message from these indicators is that despite the many efforts taken around the world to conserve biodiversity and use it sustainably, responses so far have not been adequate to address the scale of biodiversity loss or reduce the pressure."
On average, since 1970, wild vertebrate numbers have declined by almost one third, with highest losses in freshwater ecosystems (41%) and in the tropics (59%) (page 24). "The proportion of warm-water coral, bird, mammal and amphibian species expected to survive into the near future without additional conservation actions has declined over time." (page 29) There is more area designated as protected, but pressures on biodiversity are increasing.

Why does it matter? Well, apart from the inherent beauty of God's diverse creativity (which was part of the point of yesterday's post), here is a useful answer from page 23:
"Biodiversity is the variation that exists not just between the species of plants, animals, micro-organisms and other forms of life on the planet – but also within species, in the form of genetic diversity, and at the level of ecosystems in which species interact with one another and with the physical environment.

"This diversity is of vital importance to people, because it underpins a wide range of ecosystem services on which human societies have always depended, although their importance has often been greatly undervalued or ignored. When elements of biodiversity are lost, ecosystems become less resilient and their services threatened. More homogeneous, less varied landscapes or aquatic environments are often more vulnerable to sudden external pressures such as disease and climatic extremes."
Which brings us back to honeybees. Honeybees are not the most threatened species. They are not the most rapidly declining species. But they are becoming one of the new poster species for illustrating the economic value of biodiversity, because their contribution to the global economy through pollination is a staggering £26 billion per year (more than AU$43 billion). Honeybees are the primary pollinator for 90 commercial crops worldwide, including cotton, coffee, soya beans, clovers (used for cattle feed), nuts, sunflowers and a wide variety of fruit and vegetables, like apples, oranges, strawberries, onions and carrots. Without their work, our diet would be far less tasty, since one third of crop species grown in the US would decline, disappear or become prohibitively expensive.

But since 2006, honeybees in many countries have shown alarming drops in population, often with entire colonies suddenly collapsing (in what has been creatively called colony collapse disorder). As yet, the causes are not well established. Although this problem is not global and its severity can be overstated, it is nonetheless emblematic of our dependence upon a highly complex and only partially understood network of life which is rapidly unravelling under our influence.
Bee troubles have even made their way into Douglas Coupland's most recent novel, Generation A, something of a belated sequel to his iconic novel Generation X (which coined the phrase). Not far into the future, bees have apparently been driven into functional extinction, and the narrative traces the tales of five individuals who are all suddenly stung, becoming unlikely symbols of hope in a world grown more fragile and desperate. It wasn't a perfect novel, but it was fun. I give it a bee minus.

27 comments:

Anthony Douglas said...

Ah, you're in a cryptic mood. So perhaps my comment should have read:

Eh about art?

From memory, the audio commentary on yesterday's artwork (which I'll presume you might have seen while you were back here) said something about how the colour scheme is designed to draw you in.

Well, I was sucked right in! ;-)

Anonymous said...

Rudolf Steiner gave a series of lectures in 1923 in which he predicted that in approximately 80 years time there would be a Bee catastrophe.

Which will in turn cause an agricultural and horticultural catastrophe too.

Google--Rudolf Steiner Bees

Anthony Douglas said...

Wow. Rudolf was only out by four years!

byron smith said...

Calculating the cost of biodiversity loss.

byron smith said...

"The economic case for global action to stop the destruction of the natural world is even more powerful than the argument for tackling climate change, a major report for the United Nations will declare this summer." See here for more.

byron smith said...

Bee losses linked to common pesticides.

byron smith said...

SMH: Bees in Oz face invasion of mite.

byron smith said...

Pollinator decline leads to, well, pollination decline.

byron smith said...

The answer to the missing bees...

...or is it?

byron smith said...

Michael Tobis has a rant about bee story B (my second link) and the omni-suspicion of corporately-funded research.

byron smith said...

Pollinator decline in India affecting crop yields.

byron smith said...

Avaaz: Save the bees.

byron smith said...

Small scale beekeeping 101.

byron smith said...

More on colony collapse disorder and pesticides.

byron smith said...

Guardian: Bees suffer from globalisation says UN study.

byron smith said...

Guardian: honeybees decline over winter.

byron smith said...

Independent: Studies continue to identify pesticide as most likely cause of CCD.

byron smith said...

Guardian: Honeybee problem reaching a critical point. Losses continue at about 30% per year (!).

byron smith said...

Guardian: Pesticide threat to bees now clear.

Since I first posted this story (actually for a few years before that), this question has been an open one, with research gradually closing in on the answer. It seems like the main culprit has probably now been identified. Now that the science has become (more or less) clear, will governments do the right thing?

byron smith said...

Planet3.0: OK, maybe the bee breakthrough thing is not so cut and dried.

byron smith said...

More research. This time in Science claiming that a virus carried by mites is critical in bee colony collapse. Summary in the Guardian.

byron smith said...

Yale360: EU bans neonicotinoids. Discussion of the reasons.

byron smith said...

(See also FB thread from late April 2013 for numerous other links and associated discussion.)

byron smith said...

Guardian: EU bans another pesticide out of bee concern.

byron smith said...

Treehugger: Another relevant study finds that the problem lies with a particular cocktail of pesticides and fungicides.

byron smith said...

Common Dreams: Time running out for bees.

"Various stakeholders are taking steps to restrict the use of neonicotinoids , because the science is clear that pesticides are a leading driver of bee declines and are harming many other important and beneficial organisms, including birds, bats, butterflies, dragonflies, lacewings, ladybugs, earthworms, small mammals, amphibians, aquatic insects and soil microbes — putting food production and the environment in jeopardy. Earlier this year, a global body of twenty - nine independent scientists - the Task Force on Systemic Pesticides - reviewed more than 800 peer-reviewed studies published in the last five years, including industry-sponsored studies, and called for immediate regulatory action to restrict neonicotinoids."

byron smith said...

Earthjustice: Infographic.

Something new I learned: not only are numbers of hives collapsing, so is honey produced per hive. Probably shouldn't have been so surprising, but I hadn't thought of that before.