Tuesday, December 19, 2006

Eco on writing for others

[There is] another view common to bad writers - namely, that one writes only for oneself. Do not trust those who say so: they are dishonest and lying narcissists.

There is only one thing that you write for yourself, and that is a shopping list. It helps to remember what you have to buy, and when you have bought everything you can destroy it, because it is no use to anyone else. Every other thing that you write, you write to say something to someone.

I have often asked myself: would I still write today if they told me that tomorrow a cosmic catastrophe would destroy the universe, so that no one could read tomorrow what I wrote today?

My first instinct is to reply no. Why write if no one will read me? My second instinct is to say yes, but only because I cherish the desperate hope that, amid the galactic catastrophe, some star might survive, and in the future someone might decipher my signs. In that case writing, even on the eve of the Apocalypse, would still make sense.

One writes only for a reader. Whoever says he writes only for himself is not necessarily lying. It is just that he is frighteningly atheistic. Even from a rigorously secular point of view.

Unhappy and desperate the writer who cannot address a future reader.

-Umberto Eco, 'How I Write' in On Literature, 334.

5 comments:

cyberpastor said...

Bravo Eco,

We wright because words, written and spoken, are sacraments of He in whom and through whom all things in the cosmos are held together!

Anonymous said...

great quote.

Rory Shiner said...

Excellent quote Byron. Well spotted!

Felicity said...

Is writing for no one's eyes but your own necssarily narcissistic? I think not.
Is the audience automatically more important than the substance?
Is Eco's concept of the 'self' in his lone writer perhaps too isolated and detached to begin with?

Dave Lankshear said...

To take this down a notch into Lowbrow territory....

I have a journal that is password protected. I write to think... my brain gets cluttered, and not having a "Pensieve" I need to dump thoughts down in my journal.

So I could say that I write for myself, but to be totally honest, just like George Castanza I think half of it is motivated by the search for a good comeback! So in that sense it's probably rehearsing for others...but maybe not on their behalf. ;-)

(And maybe to record some bitter events and let off some steam and write things I wish I'd said but only thought of 3 hours after the event!!!! Don't you just HATE that?).

Do you think there's a password that can keep the Lord out? It gets kinda feral in there sometimes.